• Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Galleries
  • Browse
  • Login
  • Register

Near Disaster

Should we expect the worst in Twenty Ten?

Location: Johannesburg, South Africa

April 11, 2001, in South African football, is as traumatic a date as any. In fact, it is a date that is supposed to serve as a cautionary tale to the perils of football and the near-fatal devotion it attracts all over the world.

Yet, after the chaotic scenes during Nigeria’s friendly international against North Korea over the weekend, many observers will be left wondering whether South Africa learnt anything from the events of April 11, nine years ago. On that fateful date in Johannesburg, euphoria swiftly morphed into tragedy after 43 fans lost their lives trying to catch a glimpse of the famous Sowetan derby between rivals Orlando Pirates and Kaiser Chiefs.

It was a dark date that drew a judicial inquiry, caused much soul-searching in the young nation and even more relevantly, almost torpedoed South Africa’s bid to host the World Cup. 

Quickly declared the worst sporting accident in the history of South Africa, the Ellis Park disaster served as a lethal witness to the catastrophic cocktail that an uncoordinated crowd and poor event management could brew.  

As the horrific scenes at Ellis Park were beamed live on national TV to a captivated public, it felt a bit like driving past a train wreck. We knew the scenes unfolding were harrowing, but no-one could bring themselves to look away. The moral lesson of 30,000 extra fans trying to cram into the already full 60,000 capacity stadium should have remained imprinted on the nation’s psyche forever. Only it seems it was not!

If the events in Makhulong last Sunday are anything to go by, and they should be, then South Africa remains one mere match away from yet another chilling reminder of Ellis Park 2001. Situated in Tembisa, over an hour’s drive from Johannesburg, Makhulong bears the 12,000-seater Stadium that played host to Nigeria’s build-up friendly against fellow World Cup finalists North Korea.The Makhulong Stadium though, with its concrete terraces and lack of turnstiles, is far-divorced from those constructed for the World Cup. 

Why the popular and religiously supported Super Eagles chose such a “remote and small ground” to host their final warm-up match remains in question. But as thousands of football fans stampeded the gates and crushed a luckless policeman in their attempt to access the stadium, one thing was vividly clear: staging such a match in Makhulong had been a criminally wretched idea.

Moses Idowu watched the carnage unfold from the main gate and he attributed the near-disaster in Makhulong to a typically African failure to plan with foresight. “This can only happen in Africa,” Idowu bitterly lamented. “Even conservative estimates must have prepared the organizers of this match for a relatively large crowd. Yet they hosted this match in such a remote and small ground.”

One starts to dismiss Idowu’s remarks as more evidence of lazy racial stereotyping until Idowu, bedecked in a Nigerian flag and clutching the world-famous vuvuzela, points out that the people outside the stadium outnumbered those allowed inside.

“This match should have been played in a bigger stadium in Johannesburg,” Idowu insisted.

His comments dovetail sharply those of Jamilah Iyabo, a female fan dressed in Nigerian colours but with nowhere to go. Iyabo arrived an hour before the game but was refused entry by security who insisted the stadium was full to the rafters.

“This is rubbish,” she said. “There are so many Nigerians in South Africa, this match was held on a Sunday and the tickets were free. Why then, was it hosted in such a small stadium? This was an accident waiting to happen. Look around and see how many people are stuck outside. Then look and see how few are inside.”

Over 20 people got injured in the repeated fracas that occurred outside the gates while Nigeria and North Korea did battle inside Makhulong. A few fans were left relieved and wondering how fatalities were avoided and the number of casualties remained so low given the human tide that impatiently tried to force its way into the stadium.

“It could and should have been worse, my friend,” Hassan Osuafor said. “It was a miracle that no one died. There were so many people, all convinced there were empty seats inside the stadium and all desperate to somehow get in despite security claims that it was full.”

Sunday Ibweke, a portrait of frustration alongside Osuafor added: “Matters were actually helped by the fact that this match was against North Korea, which had no supporters here. Imagine what would have happened had it been a match against an equally popular side?” It’s a rhetorical question that doesn’t bear thinking about.

When Ellis Park 2001 happened all those years ago, South Africans were incensed that the nation had failed to heed lessons from 10 years earlier when a similar catastrophe occurred at the 23,000 capacity Oppenheimer Stadium during a “friendly” between Chiefs and Pirates. Back then, the Oppenheimer had been overrun by some 30,000 fans who caused a mass stampede, killing 42 people including two children.

South African legend Lucas Radebe witnessed the Oppenheimer tragedy as a Kaizer Chiefs player and hoped safety would improve as a result.

“Things like this do happen and you do learn from them, especially in a country which always tries to get better,” Radebe said back in 1991. “Things will improve. This highlights some of the problems and hopefully things like this will never happen now.”

When Ellis Park 2001 happened, time proved Radebe wrong.

However, in an echo of the Leeds United icon, then-South African president Thabo Mbeki vowed that it was “important that every element of this [Ellis Park] tragedy be looked at so that we can take all the necessary measures to make sure that we don’t have this thing happening again”.

Mbeki was further emulated by the judicial inquiry of commission into the Ellis Park disaster, which authored a 130-page final report that issued red cards to all involved in the management of the match on the fateful day.

The report, released to the public on September 26, 2002, decried an appalling lack of efficient event preplanning, identified 14 strategic and tactical failures that contributed to the disaster and made “recommendations to prevent a similar occurrence”.

Which all begs the question: Were those judicial recommendations implemented “to prevent a similar occurrence” or was the report left on the bureaucratic shelves to gather dust?

After what happened in Makhulong, some might be tempted to go with the latter. Chief among the judicial inquiry’s proposals was the need for “accurate crowd estimates for proper event safety planning”. Cited as recommendation VIII, its implementation was conspicuous by its absence in Makhulong last Sunday. Though Hangwani Mulaudzi, the police spokesman at the scene, insisted the authorities had concrete security plans in place, he admitted that they were caught offside by the events before and during the Nigeria-North Korea friendly.

“I think this is one of those isolated cases where we did not anticipate the large number of people who would be interested in this game,” Mulaudzi confessed. He hastened to add, though, that because this was a friendly build-up, Nigeria, the designated hosts were responsible for the security. “World Cup security was not available at the match because it was a friendly. Nigeria was responsible for ensuring that some security was in place nonetheless.”

The South African police weren’t the only authorities rushing to wash their hands clean of the Makhulong mess. FIFA, accused in some quarters of granting free tickets to the match, instantly released a press statement distancing itself from the whole affair.

“FIFA and the [World Cup] Organising Committee would like to reiterate that this friendly match has no relation whatsoever with the operational organisation of the 2010 FIFA World Cup, for which we remain fully confident. Contrary to some media reports, FIFA had nothing to do with the ticketing of this game.”

The Nigerian Football Federation, however, refused to concede liability. “Nobody can be blamed for this,” NFF official Taiwo Ogunjobi said. “We did not have any choice of an alternate bigger venue. We are just thankful nobody died. The tickets were free and too many people wanted to get in.” The blame-shifting game will be made more heated by the fact that as public relations calamities go, Makhulong was an ill-timed one.

Just hours earlier, at the presidential guest house in Pretoria, Jacob Zuma had officially welcomed the World Cup with a triumphant, “We’re Ready” and police chief Nathi Mthethwa revealed that his charges were prepared to protect both VIPs and ordinary fans. The fact that a few other recommendations of the post-Ellis Park judicial report were glaring by their non-existence at Makhulong made a mockery of such assurances; the most obvious absentee being the one about motor-parking. When the judicial probe discovered that the Ellis Park disaster had been worsened by the traffic nightmare that denied fast access to emergency vehicles, its final judicial report urged stadiums to ensure sufficient parking as a prerequisite to hosting matches. Makhulong didn’t bother to comply with this on Sunday.

With limited parking around the stadium, surrounding roads were gridlocked; cars were parked haphazardly along all entry points with nary a traffic officer in sight.

Japhta Mombelo, an injured fan bleeding from a head wound outside the ground, revealed: “The crowd just overpowered me, I went down and people just fell over me. The police told me to stay around and they would organise an ambulance, but I am still waiting.”

The ambulances did eventually screech their way onto the scene.

That nothing so drastic happened to make emergency vehicles such a critical ingredient to the entire Makhulong bedlam was perhaps the day’s only saving grace. That, and the fact that Makhulong serves as a timely reminder to all stakeholders that, with the World Cup just five days away, authorities can ill-afford the luxury of leaving security and safety to the vagaries of chance again.

    X
    Image Number: APN292167
    Title: TTicon
    Path: african.pictures / Twenty Ten / Nikki Rixon
    Description: T10logo
    Collections: Independent Photographers
    Subcollections: Nikki Rixon
    Orientation: portrait
    Pixel Size: 2500 x 3308
    Media Id: 1_741
    Credit: Nikki Rixon / Africa Media Online
    Property Release: No

Main Menu
  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Galleries
  • Blog
Legal
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Help

Africa Media Online

2007/004727/07

PRIVACY POLICY

THIS PRIVACY POLICY (“POLICY”) GOVERNS THE PROCESSING OF PERSONAL INFORMATION BY AFRICA MEDIA ONLINE IN CONNECTION WITH AFRICA MEDIA ONLINE’S ARCHIVE WEBSITE (“WEBSITE”) LOCATED AT [https://african.pictures/]. YOUR USE OF THE WEBSITE IS SUBJECT TO THIS POLICY. BY USING THIS WEBSITE, YOU SIGNIFY YOUR CONSENT TO PROCESSING OF YOUR PERSONAL INFORMATION IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS PRIVACY POLICY.

AFRICA MEDIA ONLINE MAY AMEND THIS POLICY AT ANY TIME. AMENDED TERMS SHALL BE EFFECTIVE IMMEDIATELY UPON THE POSTING OF THE REVISED POLICY AND ANY SUBSEQUENT ACTIVITY IN RELATION TO THE WEBSITE SHALL BE GOVERNED BY SUCH AMENDED TERMS. IF YOU DO NOT AGREE WITH ANY TERM IN THIS POLICY, PLEASE DO NOT USE THIS WEBSITE.

This Agreement was last revised on 31-03-2020.
Enquiries: Kate Dearlove

  1. PERSONAL INFORMATION COLLECTION AND USE
    1. Subject to consent, Africa Media Online collects, stores and uses information from Archive Content Subjects (persons whose personal information is determined from the digitisation or digital processing of records belonging to Africa Media Online) for the following purposes:
      1. to compile and maintain an archive for Africa Media Online,
      2. to be published in marketing and communications materials, including but not limited to, school magazines, brochures, newsletters and published photographs on the Website or otherwise,
      3. to provide the Archive Content Subjects with direct marketing communications regarding Africa Media Online’s activities and news.
    2. We collect Personal Information from the following persons:
      1. natural persons over 18,
      2. natural persons under 18 with the consent of a competent person,
      3. juristic persons such as companies duly represented by a representative,
      4. people who send enquiries or requests to our contact email address.
    3. Categories of persons listed in clause 1.4 may include Website Users and Archive Content Subjects and in certain instances persons may categorised as both.
    4. Africa Media Online may also automatically collect and store non-personally identifiable information from Your use of the Website.
    5. Africa Media Online may collect the following personal information from Website Users:
      1. name,
      2. surname,
      3. username and password,
      4. job description,
      5. organisation name,
      6. organisation type,
      7. organisation URL,
      8. email address,
      9. telephone number,
      10. mobile telephone number,
      11. facsimile number,
      12. address,
      13. city and province,
      14. postal code,
      15. country,
      16. type of organisation,
      17. the market the organisation serves,
      18. non-personal browsing habits and click patterns,
      19. IP address,
      20. purchasing information and buying patterns,
      21. any additional information necessary to deliver our services,
      22. details of responses to Your enquiries and any online communications between us and You, and
      23. any information provided to us by You.
    6. Africa Media Online may collect the following personal information from Archive Content Subjects: 1.8.1 name,
      1. name,
      2. surname,
      3. date of birth,
      4. age,
      5. gender,
      6. race,
      7. language,
      8. culture,
      9. physical health,
      10. ethnic origin,
      11. education information,
      12. religion,
      13. disability,
      14. marital status,
      15. pregnancy,
      16. mental health,
      17. biometric information,
      18. location information,
      19. employment history,
      20. personal opinions, views or preferences,
      21. The views or opinions of another individual about the person;
      22. videos recordings,
      23. audio recordings,
      24. manuscripts,
      25. photographs, and
      26. any additional information that can form part of the archive of Africa Media Online.
    7. We may use cookies or other tracking technologies to collect information such as the pages You visit or the information You request. The Website hosting agents and/or service providers may automatically log Your “IP address” which is a unique identifier for Your computer and/or other access device. Such information collected is for aggregate purposes only.
  2. CONSENT TO PROCESS YOUR PERSONAL INFORMATION
    1. If You are a Website User, You consent to the processing of Your Personal Information specifically including (i) to greet the User when he/she accesses the Website, (ii) to inform the Website User of facts relating to his/her access and use of the Website as well as to assist with problems, (iii) to provide the Website User with access to the Website and the associated Website services, (iv) to provide the Website User with direct marketing communications regarding Africa Media Online’s activities and news, and/or (v) to compile non-personal statistical information about browsing habits, click-patterns and access to the Website.
    2. If You are an Archive Content Subject, You consent to the processing of Your Personal Information specifically including (i) to compile and maintain an archive for Africa Media Online, (ii) to be published in marketing and communications materials, including but not limited to, school magazines, brochures, newsletters and published photographs on the Website or otherwise, and/or (iii) to provide the You with direct marketing communications regarding Africa Media Online’s activities and news.
    3. The processing of Your Personal Information shall include the collection, receipt, recording, organisation, collation, storage, updating or modification, retrieval, alteration, consultation, use; dissemination by means of transmission, distribution or making available in any other form; or merging, linking, as well as blocking, degradation, erasure or destruction of information.
    4. By using our Website, You represent that You are of the age of 18 or older or that you have necessary authorisation from a competent person and that you consent to Your Personal Information to be processed by Africa Media Online.
    5. You expressly consent to Africa Media Online retaining Your Personal Information once Your relationship with Africa Media Online has been terminated for: aggregate, statistical, reporting and historical purposes.
    6. In the event that You wish to revoke all consent pertaining to Your Personal Information and/or You would like Africa Media Online to remove and/or delete Your Personal Information entirely, You may contact Africa Media Online via email to [pictures@africamediaonline.com]
  3. HANDLING OF PERSONAL INFORMATION
    1. Africa Media Online endeavours to comply with all laws and regulations applicable to Africa Media Online pertaining to information and communications privacy including, but not limited to, the 1996 South African Constitution and the Protection of Personal Information Act 4 of 2013 (“the Act”). Africa Media Online applies the principles of protection of Personal Information under such Act and further legislation referred to in the Act.
    2. Africa Media Online seeks to ensure the quality, accuracy and confidentiality of Personal Information in its possession. You warrant that all personal information supplied by You is both true and correct at the time of provision. In the event of any aspect of Your personal information changing post submission, it is Your responsibility to immediately notify Africa Media Online of the said changes by email to Kate Dearlove. You agree to indemnify and hold Africa Media Online, its officers, directors, employees, agents, and suppliers harmless from and against any claims, damages, actions and liabilities including without limitation, indirect, incidental, special, consequential or punitive damages arising out of Africa Media Online’s reliance on Your personal information should Your personal information contain any errors or inaccuracies.
    3. You warrant that You have the authority, permissions and consents to provide Africa Media Online with any third party information submitted to Africa Media Online.
    4. Africa Media Online will take all reasonable measures in order to ensure Your Personal Information is appropriately safeguarded, these precautions include, but are not limited to: access control mechanisms via username and password, and software protection for information for security.
    5. Should an unauthorised person/s gain access to Your Personal Information Africa Media Online will contact You within a reasonable time to inform You of such access.
    6. Africa Media Online may share Your PersonaI Information with authorised third parties such as service providers to Africa Media Online. These include, but are not limited to digital archiving service providers. Africa Media Online does not permit these parties to use such information for any other purpose than to perform the services that Africa Media Online has instructed them to provide. All processing is compatible with such purpose.
    7. Africa Media Online may appoint certain agents, third parties and/or service providers which operate outside the borders of the Republic of South Africa. In these circumstances Africa Media Online will be required to transmit Your Personal Information outside South Africa. The purpose of the trans-border transfer of Your Personal Information may include, but is not limited to: data hosting and storage. You expressly consent to the trans-border flow of Your Personal Information.
    8. The Website may contain links to other websites. Africa Media Online is not responsible for the privacy practices of such third party websites.
  4. RECORDS OF PERSONAL INFORMATION
    1. Records relating to the provision of Africa Media Online products and/or services by Africa Media Online to You and the Personal Information submitted by You is retained for publication on the Website and/or to provide you with the Website services.
    2. Such records may be required to be retained in terms of legislated records retention requirements, Africa Media Online’ operational purposes and/or for production as evidence by Africa Media Online in legal proceedings.
    3. In terms of Section 14(2) of the Act records of personal information may be retained for periods in excess of those contemplated in 4.1 for historical purposes. Africa Media Online warrants that appropriate safeguards are in place to prevent the records being used for any other purpose.
    4. Africa Media Online may disclose Your Personal Information under the following circumstances: 4.4.1 To comply with the law or with legal process;
      1. To protect and defend Africa Media Online’s rights, equipment, facilities and other property;
      2. To protect Africa Media Online against misuse or unauthorised use of the Website and/or products and/or services; and/or
      3. To protect other Website Users or third parties affected negatively by Your actions in use of the products/services and/or the Website.
  5. ACCEPTABLE USE
    In connection with the Digital Archive Material (as made available through the Website) You agree that:

    1. No Item containing the image of or reference to a person is to be used for a purpose other than for which rights are granted by Africa Media Online, without prior express written permission of Africa Media Online.
    2. Only a single digital copy of an Item may be stored on a single computer, hard drive, or any other storage device, and that that copy may not be duplicated in any way whatsoever, except for a single backup copy which may only be used in the event of the original being deleted, lost, or irreparably damaged.
    3. Once the Item has been used for the purpose for which use rights were granted, all copies of the Item must be deleted, apart from where it forms part of the archive of what was published.
  6. OBJECTIONS, COMPLAINTS AND QUERIES
    1. Should You have any questions about this Privacy Policy, require a correction to be made to Your Personal Information that Africa Media Online keeps on record, request a copy of the record itself, lodge an objection to the collection, Use or processing of Your Personal Information by Africa Media Online, or delete Your personally identifiable information, you may send an e-mail to [pictures@africamediaonline.com]
    2. There may be instances where we cannot grant You access to the Personal Information we hold. We may need to refuse access if granting access would interfere with the privacy of others or if it would result in a breach of confidentiality. Should this be the case, we will give You written reasons for any refusal.

Confirm Order

Please confirm that you would like to order a high quality version of this item. Once your order is placed, a request for approval will be sent to the relevant archivist who may respond to you with questions. If your order is approved, you will be notified and the file will be made available for download.

Loading...

Login

Lost your password?

Register

Login

Please enter login details below.



Forgot your password?
Register Now

Register

Note: Your password will be generated automatically and sent to your email address.